Blog
You are looking at: Home : Blog

The Tavistock: not everyone's Cup of tea

Call it what you want, but the inter-club battle means a lot to many

Posted: 16 March 2011
by Alex Perry

The victorious Lake Nona side

“Can’t wait for the Tavistock Cup? No, me either. Worst. Golf Tournament. Ever.”

Not my words, the tweeted droll of Lawrence Donegan.

“Why is it the worst golf tournament ever?” snapped participant Ian Poulter, taking immediate exception. “Explain yourself, ‘cause that’s bollocks.”

“It’s obnoxiously exclusive,” explained Donegan, as requested. “It’s ostentatious and over-hyped.”

This from a man who writes for the Guardian.

“Ah, did someone not get invited?” asked Poulter.

“If I wanted a ticket, I could have got one!” replied Donegan, descending the argument quickly into a battle of my-dad’s-bigger-than-your-dad playground wit.

But the English Ryder Cup star made one very valid point: “How about the $8million that has been donated to charity from the Tavistock Cup?” And you can’t argue with charity.

Suddenly, my Twitter feed was overloading with people getting their dig in at the Tavistock Cup. Before the first ball had left the tee at Isleworth Golf & Country Club, I’d read the words ‘nauseating’, ‘meaningless’, ‘insularity’ and, well, ‘nauseating’ a couple more times.

“Why is it even televised?” asked one golf fan, akin to those who spend their evenings whining to the Daily Mail about an Eastenders storyline. 

Just. Turn. Over.

Elsewhere, Golf Digest’s Ron Sirak makes his feelings known. Last year, Sirak famously attended the country club competition before leaving without even getting past the parking lot.

Why? Because he refused to wear the polo shirt given to him by the organisers.

“In the spirit of journalism, I cannot wear your corporate uniform while I am covering your event,” argued Sirak. “I am here as a journalist, not as a billboard.”

Now, I’m not going to sit here and slate one of the finest golf writers of our time, and I admire his principles. But he was there to do a job and should have done it.  

At a previous job, I was asked to go and interview a not-so-famous footballer. Before the meeting, I had an email requesting I wore a suit, despite it being a one-on-one in a dingy conference room of a lower-league football team.

Finding this amusing, I mentioned it my editor. “So wear a suit then,” he replied. “I don’t care if he asks you to wear a f***ing Santa Claus outfit. I want the story, so do it.” Despite missing my point just a little bit, he had a point. Sirak should have worn the shirt. But he saw a way out and he grabbed it with both hands, via an acid tongue.

So how do I feel about the Tavistock Cup? Honestly, I can give or take it. It’s played on a Monday and Tuesday, so hardly squeezed in to replace a regular Tour event. And call me a bit of a maverick, but as a golf fan I enjoy watching the best golfers playing exhibition stuff on some of the world’s finest courses.

If you’re still reading, Oliver Wilson’s inspired seven-under 65 saw him take the Payne Stewart Salver Award while his team, Lake Nona, won the World Country Club Championship at a massive 43-under.

Yes, it might be ostentatious and yes, it might be elitist. But newsflash guys, golf at every level has been all these things for years.

Wilson, a nine-time European Tour runner-up but never a winner, will have gained a whole new world of confidence from this victory. Not to mention the millions of lives that will change for the better from the millions donated.

Try telling them the Tavistock Cup is a waste of time.


Previous story
Another week, another France 2018 backing
Next story
It's Ryder Cup back-slapping time again!

Oliver Wilson, Tavistock Cup, Ian Poulter, Graeme McDowell
TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle


Discuss this story

Good stuff, Alex shame you told me the result, though. I taped the recording, so I could watch it in peace at my leisure! (only kidding, it was my job to know the result before I recorded the replay! You've just taken the fun out of it, that's all ;-))

Some of these USA journos' eh? Such hypocrites. You're not going to tell me they don't put a bit of verbal product placement in their copy sometimes to appease the MD's advertisers or accept the odd putter or wedge for turning up to play in a pro-am.

Principles?... what principles? Just looking for an excuse not to be accused of being in public relations, if you ask me, while most of the time they're sucking up to the Tiger Woods entourage, star-struck in their designer polos, fresh out of a goodie bag.

From what I've seen of the Tavistock Cup so far it was a relaxed event with David Feherty and Gary McCord the star turns and the players really trying on a course that's as aspirational as you can get. ED

Posted: 16/03/2011 at 14:19

"Yes, it might be ostentatious and yes, it might be elitist. But newsflash guys, golf at every level has been all these things for years."

Hmmm. So that's a good reason for perpetuating and reinforcing the stereotype is it? 

I watched some of the coverage on tv. I found it very difficult to get excited or inspired by any of it to be honest.  I found it self-congratulatory and self-indulgent. G Mac's mum seems very nice but not sure why there was a need for an extended interview with her. 

I saw Feherty interviewing Tiger last night, he was fluttering his eyelids and looking like he was soiling his pants to be so close to his hero!

Sorry, but not really my cup of tea. 

That said it's very American to raise lots of money for charity and to be self congratulatory about doing so.  Can't knock the result i guess, even if you have to applaud their egos through gritted teeth


Posted: 16/03/2011 at 14:31

Is there any proof of the money donations that are claimed? I seem to remember reading something with some values much much less than that.

Posted: 16/03/2011 at 15:03

I must say, I enjoy watching the golf played and the location.  But do find the ostentatious pampering of the pro's ott.  Players being helicoptered in to the club one example.  I'm all for charity events like this one, I just wonder how many of them would be playing if there was nothing in it for themselves.   Oli Wilson, made $200,000 for just a single round of golf in a field of just 24.  Also, one of the teams of 6 came away with speedboats for simply having a nearest the pin.


Posted: 16/03/2011 at 16:16

I heard somewhere that Golf contributes more to charity than the next 4 sports combined. If my sport can do that who cares if the top dogs flash it around a bit.. I was glad for Oli Wilson so long the nearly man, I didnt know he was living in the States, or was he a invite like Woods??  As for watching it, I saw some and liked the spirit under which the event was conducted I dont particularily find Feherty humourous but he did the best he could under the circumstances.. I would quite like it if they made it a mixed event playing Greensomes etc or how about a scramble?? seeing pros playing a scramble might be fun..at least that would make it a bit different!!

Posted: 16/03/2011 at 16:49

i couldnt give a monkeys how much pampering and rear end licking the golfers get whilst playing the tavistock cup .

its golf on the telly and relaxed golf at that. its all for a good cause and sponsors line up to throw money at it and the charitys inovolved.

 it makes a change for players to be interviewed mid round and have a laugh about the days play .

so they get pampered who cares ,i dont .


Posted: 16/03/2011 at 18:09

Personally can't stand watching it, but I take my own advice and simply don't watch it!!   Not too difficult.

Posted: 16/03/2011 at 18:12

It's one of those events that has just grown and grown. What started as a bit of fun amongst some mates cetainly has grown in to something pretty big. Probably all the the TV coverage.

For me though only an event to have on in the background whilst  on the computer.


Posted: 16/03/2011 at 20:58

absolutely agree with Funky. it is the first time i have watched it (i managed to find it online) and it was great to see such a relaxed atmosphere and the players taking the mickey out of each, and money going to good causes.

Posted: 16/03/2011 at 21:26

The pro's and celebs were pampered rotten at Gleneagles when the BBC filmed pro-celeb golf in the 70's and 80's. The old Crosby Clam Bake, an archetypal PGA Tour charity pro-am, also saw the pro's wined, dined and partied by the Hollywood A-list. Nothing has changed, and press grumbling is just envy in my book

Posted: 16/03/2011 at 22:44

Talkback: The Tavistock: not everyone's Cup of tea

First Name:
Last Name:
Nickname:
Email:
Security Image:
Enter the code shown:

I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct: