Welcome to GOLFmagic
Why should I become a member?
  •  
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Golf Courses
  • Golf Instruction
  • Golf Travel
  • Directory
  • Golf Forums
  • Golf Competitions
Join GolfMagic  
Advertise with us  
Take our articles (RSS)  
General News  
Tour News  
Equipment news  
Mens golf clubs  
Ladies golf clubs  
Golf bags and trolleys  
Competitions and give-aways  
Golf shoes and clothing  
Golf balls  
Golf books and videos  
Junior golf clubs  
Golf accessories  
Gear news  
Buyers' guides  
Shopping  
Book tee times  
Read and write course reviews  
Shopping  
Free handicap and score tracker  
Driving  
Putting  
Rescue shots  
General tips  
Golf travel offers  
Golf travel overseas  
Score tracker  
Tee Time Finder  
Shopping  
Travel  
Classifieds  
Golf Forums
You are looking at: Home : Golf Forums : Golf equipment
Will you be going square?
 
Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum TopicsHelp | Settings | Public Profile
 Search forum: 
Will you be going square?
1 to 19 of 19 messages
 
Show/hide user stats
The Space Golfer
20/03/07 18:49
 1760 forum posts 1 review
How many of you think you'll be buying one of the square drivers. The science seems sound behind them, the magazines (surprise, surprise) say they're great.

Personally, I'll be waiting till they've been out for a while and see what people think, then maybe try one out. I'm probably in the majority.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Peter Robertson 3
20/03/07 19:14
 285 forum posts
The Callaway FTI looks very appealing to me, although at that kind of money it's pathetic, a pure marketing con, I'll wait a year or so when more OEM'S start making Square drivers then and look again then.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
blacky(6)
20/03/07 19:40
 551 forum posts
yes totally agree with you peter. i think i will wait for the hype and prices to fall.feedback from some golf mags suggest you will hit it straighter but not any further.this doesnt appeal to me at the moment as i am not a long hitter and i am always looking for extra distance.i will probably try one anyway.i think it is always best to try for yourself as you can read to much in to hype in magazines.i have just bought an ft3, so i will give this a few months anyway.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
John Foster (16)
20/03/07 19:53
 1362 forum posts 3 reviews 1 bookmark
There is one born every minute and it appears to be me. Can't wait for my club to get all the demo clubs in so I can try them out on the course.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
reni
20/03/07 21:31
 45 forum posts 1 review
I won't be changing very happy with my cobra 440sz
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Stuart Beresford-Kelly
20/03/07 21:47
 84 forum posts 1 review
I've got an XQ Muto on the way. It gets a good name and costs a 1/3 of what the Nike and Callaways do. I'm after accuracy and forgiveness at this point. Booming it 270 yards or more can wait. If I can hit the Muto up to about 230 yards and straight I'll be happy. As my game improves, who knows, maybe I'll be able to hit it 270 yards or so.

At lot of people on here say the right club for the right player. If a square driver is right for me then who is anyone else to comment? The same goes for chippers and long handle putters etc. if you don't want one then don't buy one. As long as the club is legal it's no one elses business what you have in your bag. I'm sure there was uproar back when metal woods first appeared.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Taz
21/03/07 08:33
 10814 forum posts 6 articles 59 reviews
I won't be going square.
Square drivers are right up there with all the other gimmicky golf tat that I abhor.
Two ball putters (and other spud mashers)
Irons with plastic crap in the back
Golf shoes with R-soles for extra distance
Golf clubs with half B&Q's nut and bolt section attached.
Putters that are not freely swung from a single grip


I will campaign tirelessly to humiliate the duffers who use them

:o)


 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Stuart
21/03/07 09:03
 794 forum posts 13 reviews
Taz you're not using a 460cc titanium driver with graphite shaft are you ? I hate people who don't use persimmon woods with steel shafts... bloody cheats if you ask me !! ;-)
And don't get me started on non balata balls
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
The23rdman
21/03/07 09:13
 3213 forum posts 2 reviews
Is it now hip to be square? (sorry!)

Not for me, thanks. I'm happy(ish) with my old 975D :-)
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Ossie (7.1)
21/03/07 10:01
 2431 forum posts 12 reviews
I'vre tried the Nike SQ2...hated its looks but the club performed OK...pretty straight and similar distance to my existing driver but nothing special.

Also tried the Cally Fti the other night...quite like its quirky looks but the stiff Fujikura shaft in it is a POS for me all I could do with this club was put great big high slices into the air.

Two clubs hit....current impressions arent great, I certainly wont be buying one. Might try getting hold of a clone head (like an Integra) and putting my own shaft preference in and seeing how that goes.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Rob Milligan (10.7)
21/03/07 10:34
 994 forum posts 19 reviews
The FTi was a real possibility for me this year, (pending demo results), however I just recently picked up a tour issued Taylor Made R5 TP with stiff Diamana 83 shaft for less than a 3rd of the FTi's retail and let me tell you....The R5 TP is the real deal!

Ps. I do think that the 'square thing' will be nothing more than a passing fad.(not that I wouldn't have partaken!!!)
 Send to friend
Edited: 21/03/07 10:35
Show/hide user stats
Taz
21/03/07 10:50
 10814 forum posts 6 articles 59 reviews
Stu - nothing to do with maxing the limits (although I think they are too lenient)

.... it's called 'taste'.

:o)


Was talking to my local pro earlier - he reckons the fad will pass, as soon as a few mugs buy 'em and their clever mates try 'em.
He did say - out the middle of the bat there is no diff whatsoever. They may be more forgiving for crap players though.
His recommendation for top driver - "You cannot beat a Taylor Made 580 with a shaft that suits you"
From the horses - honest!

The Guv'nor @ 99 bucks (shaft is too stiff for me - bugger!)





 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Dave Bhoy
21/03/07 10:52
 224 forum posts
tried the square nike one at the range yesterday

horrible horrible horrible
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Macio
21/03/07 12:52
 23 forum posts
Well .. i will wait and see ..

Just bought of Ebay FT-3 with Aldilla NVS Stiff 65grams shaft. costed me £94.

Wait a year and square driver (used ones) we will get for a hundred if we want one :)

Macio
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Macio
21/03/07 12:54
 23 forum posts
Taz - funny you said that .. i still use my R580XD with NVS shaft ... tried R7 and it didn't hit any longer. We will see with FT-3 be any longer :)

Macio
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
JimP (7.5)
21/03/07 13:05
 6124 forum posts 21 reviews
Taz

Totally agree with the comment about
Taylor R580

I go to all the demo days (my pro is a main agent for most manufacturers) and have still yet to find anything better. Although I do feel it is mainly because I have found a shaft that is totally suited to my swing.

I put the same shaft in a real cheapy head and got nearly the same results.

My R540 Tour with the same shaft in works just as well but has less loft so I stick with the R580, the R540 Tour is probably what I will revert to in 2008. Trouble is that is not what the manufacturers want to hear.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Birdie Boy (11.5) WooHoo
21/03/07 13:33
 1472 forum posts
I have the XQ Muto with Grafalloy Blue65 regurlar shaft and it is great. I have now found the the correct shaft for me as I also have this shaft in the Ben Ross S4 3wood. I tried the stiff Blue65 but found it too stiff, even though I swing at around 105mph with a driver. Switched back to the regurlar (only cost £2 postage back to 14clubs.com) and now hitting the furthest and straightest I have ever hit.
Sunday, par 4 up hill, do not know yardage,
ended up 10yds from the front edge of the green (last 10 yds is very steep up hill).
Never hit this far before and hopefully in the spring/summer I might be able to reach the green.

Now, comments above have got me thinking.
I have a TM R580XD spare, what if I change the shaft to a Blue65 Reg? Will it mean I am then competing with the big boys or will it trash my game? I reckon it might be worth finding out.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Macio
21/03/07 15:35
 23 forum posts
If you are sure that the shaft is right then give it a shot ... if it will not work out then you still got your current driver that you can play with ...

Macio
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
blacky(6)
21/03/07 16:44
 551 forum posts
macio, was it a second hand ft3? how does it perform?

taz, disagree with some of your comments on gimmicky equipment. i think the two ball putter is the best thing since sliced bread. dont fancy square drivers though. think they will die off quickly.what next a square golf ball?
 Send to friend

 You say:
Message: (1500 character limit)
(Using the Quick Post will also register you with the site)
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
  
  
 

Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Forum jump  
Become a member and join in the forum!
Calendar
To search for a local course please enter a distance and your postcode:
To book a local tee click Here >>
Free golf score and handicap tracker. Record your stats,
analyse your round,
improve your game!
Click here
Calendar
Why Tiger chose Masters for his return - Published in News
Woods feels comfortable and secure at Augusta - 17/3/10
Golf Express airline soon to take off - Published in News
New travel idea launches in April - 12/3/10
Tiger's comeback for Bay Hill (March 25)? - Published in News
Mickelson set to lock horns with World No.1 at Arnold Palmer event - 12/3/10
  • Puma buys Cobra Golf brand
  • The English are coming!
Forgan St. Andrews - Custom Golf Clubs
TM Golf Shops
Golf Store Europe
GolfOnline.co.uk
Golfballs.gg
Great Value Golf
The Grip Master
'JamGolf - Golf Clearance'
Golfmagic on Twitter
Facebook

Become a fan of RCUK

Twitter

Follow us on twitter

Visit our sister site Bikemagic.com

Click here

Meet the Team

Click here

Other Magicalia Sites

Parenting

  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums

Active

  • AVReview
  • BIKEmagic
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • RoadCyclingUK
  • Visordown

About GOLFMagic

  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & conditions
  • Support
  • Advertise with us

Forums

  • New to the forum?
  • General
  • Magic action
  • Golf instruction
  • Golf equipment
  • Golf courses
  • Have clubs, will travel
  • Golf fitness
  • Other sports
  • Pro Tours
  • Custom-fit and club makers
  • Golf rules & handicapping
  • Fancy a game?
  • The 19th hole
  • Feedback/Help desk
  • GOLFmagic League
  • Classifieds/Swap Shop

Competitions

  • Competitions
  • Free handicap and score tracker
  • Golf travel offers
  • Online tee times

Golf Courses

  • Book tee times
  • Read and write course reviews
  • Shopping

Golf Tips

  • Free handicap and score tracker
  • Driving
  • Putting
  • Rescue shots
  • General tips

Travel

  • Golf travel offers
  • Golf travel overseas

Home

  • Join GOLFMagic
  • Advertise with us
  • Take our articles (RSS)

News

  • News
  • Tour News
  • Equipment News

Reviews

  • Competitions and give-aways
  • Equipment News
  • Buyers' guides
  • Shopping
© 1999-2010 Magicalia Ltd. Part of the Magicalia group www.magicalia.com