Saturday 30 August 2008 | Personalise | Help  
Free membership
Join GOLFmagic now
Join today and you could win a Cobra LD Driver worth £222
why join?  
Win a luxury golf break!
www.best4balls.com
Latest Reviews
4290 Total Reviews
Benross VeloCT Combo Irons
by Phil... The Golfing Drummer
FootJoy ReelFit
by Steve White (15.3)
SMT Durometer wedge black with Spinner shaft
by Steve White (15.3)
Srixon I-506
by Steve White (15.3)
adidas Golf Tour 360 Golf Shoes
by leonard shanahan
» Loads More Reviews
 FORUM REVIEWS
 
Related Categories:
Balls \ Normal balls

 FORUM
Discussions by:   Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
 Search forum: 
TG Ball review 08
1 to 8 of 8 messagesTo post a reply you need to be a member - Join now.
Show/hide user stats

For anyone interested, Today's Golfer have their big golf ball review this month. Here are a handful of numbers.

(PGA Pro, 9 deg Driver, 48 deg PW, SS unknown, LM unknown):

TP Red---------: 262yds 2972rpm, 125yds 5178rpm
TP Black--------: 269yds 2864rpm, 127yds 3690rpm
Z-URS----------: 254yds 2750rpm, 123yds 5181rpm
Z-URC----------: 268yds 2226rpm, 125yds 4256rpm
One Black ------: 265yds 3042rpm, 126yds 4984rpm
One Platinum----: 266yds 2750rpm, 128yds 4490rpm
Tour B330-------: 258yds 2844rpm, 127yds 3985rpm
Tour B330S------: 255yds 2876rpm, 125yds 4284rpm
Pro V1-----------: 264yds 2942rpm, 126yds 5324rpm
Pro V1x----------: 271yds 2681rpm, 129yds 4765rpm
Tour iX----------: 270yds 2275rpm, 129yds 4517rpm
Tour i-----------: 268yds 2561rpm, 127yds 4772rpm
Tx4 Pro---------: 257yds 2840rpm, 126yds 4647rpm

PTS Solo---------: 260yds 2253rpm, 124yds 4282rpm
NXT Extreme-----: 269yds 3426rpm, 129yds 4729rpm
NXT Tour--------: 268yds 3219rpm, 129yds 4890rpm
Big Bertha-------: 272yds 2552rpm, 128yds 4604rpm
HX Hot Bite------: 262yds 2705rpm, 128yds 4336rpm
HX Hot ----------: 268yds 1904rpm, 133yds 4327rpm
Ignite -----------: 261yds 2819rpm, 128yds 3654rpm
Power Dist Long--: 275yds 2174rpm, 138yds 2471rpm
Power Dist Soft---: 257yds 2989rpm, 125yds 3189rpm
Karma------------: 249yds 3031rpm, 127yds 4636rpm
Px3 Soft Spin-----: 258yds 3310rpm, 123yds 4539rpm
Dx2 Soft----------: 249yds 2763rpm, 126yds 4911rpm
AD333-------------: 265yds 2483rpm, 131yds 4848rpm
Trispeed----------: 263yds 2647rpm, 136yds 5141rpm
Soft Feel----------: 257yds 3001rpm, 126yds 5224rpm
Burner------------: 262yds 2839rpm, 129yds 4736rpm
Burner TP---------: 264yds 2744rpm, 127yds 5615rpm

Freak-------------: 273yds 2344rpm, 127yds 3315rpm
Gamer-------------: 266yds 2514rpm, 135yds 2730rpm
Noodle+-----------: 262yds 2706rpm, 130yds 3549rpm
Warbird-----------: 258yds 1750rpm, 124yds 3482rpm

All credit to Today's Golfer for publishing such data. Might not be to everyones taste, but some like to see it as a guide to short-listing what balls to look at in terms of distance, wedge spin, etc.  But do those results look right to everyone? Noticed a few inconsistencies that worry me. Last year they said the Wilson Staff Tx4 Pro was the longest by 9yds..now it's not even close. Also last year they claimed the budget Warbird was higher spinning than even the Pro V1 (5702rpm vs ProV1's 5215rpm), yet it's no where near this time around.

This year they seem to be saying, the Burner TP, Srixon Soft feel and Trispeed all have more wedge spin than most premium balls? The NXT Tour and Dx2 Soft spin nearly as much as a Nike One Black? The Nike Karma, Burner, NXT Extreme, AD333, etc are all up there too? Does that sound right? Or are TG's testing methods not showing up the differences correctly? Golf Magazine in the US have also published their golf ball review, but using robot testing at 2 different swing speeds. Will be interesting to compare them to TGs results.

Disappointed that once again no Bridgestone E5/E6, let alone the new E5+/E6+. To be fair to TG, it seems Bridgestone haven't bothered to properly release them over here. But had hoped TG would still include them as they get good reviews in the US for mid-priced golf balls.

Edited: 13/01/08 14:29
Show/hide user stats

It would've been interesting if they'd have tested the Inesis TD tour to compare them against the premium balls.

Show/hide user stats
What about the Bald eagle?!
Show/hide user stats

Any such data is fundementally flawed as it was carried out by a "Pga pro". Half of them would struggle to break 80, let alone put several hundred consistent swings together. An Iron Byron test is the only way to make such a comparison.

Let's just take a look at one example. The HX Hot driver data is "268yds 1904rpm" and the TP Black is "269yds 2864rpm". So a one yard difference but a huge difference in spin rate. Doesn't make sense at all.

Its TG, they most likely just made the whole thing up anyway.

Show/hide user stats

Whaaaaatttt ???????????????

You mean a PGA pro who can hit a PW over 125 yards average cannot hit driver further than 265 yards average - I don't believe it!

......perhaps they should have asked some of the handicap golfers from this forum to do the test

Show/hide user stats

Speaking as someone with a modest stats background, without knowing the standard deviation within groups it is impossible to tell whether the difference between any two sample groups is significant (ie whether it implies a real-world difference in performance).

What that means is that there might be just as much variability between one group of - what did they count, six hits? - and the next just by natural variation of swing, strike etc as there is because of using different balls. Maybe if they'd used all ProV1s and just made up names for each group, you'd see the same sort of pattern. That would certainly explain why the relative rankings of different balls across the two years' tests is not consistent.

For, example, I tossed different coins six times each and got the following results:

£2: 2 heads 4 tails 

£1: 3 heads, 3 tails

50p: 3 heads 3 tails

20p: 5 heads 1 tail

10p: 2 heads 4 tails

I therefore conclude that if you want a head, you should in general use a seven-sided coin rather than a round one. Absolute rubbish, of course, but a desperate hack could get an article out of it.

Show/hide user stats

hope they took an average of a number of shots. These ball tests are a load of balls , my advice find a ball that suits you're all round game , something not about distance though .

Played with a guy recently (23 handicap) who was losing balls on every holes , i can honestly say he pulled a different ball out of his bag everytime he lost one.

When i commented on this , he said he buys bags of lakeballs from a well known sports shop as he knows he will be losing about 5-10 balls a round and can't afford to buy new.

I use Callway HX Tour and buy them from ebay , last purchase £5.30 + £3.00 P+P , for pearl grade.

Show/hide user stats
im with creo on this one, unless you standardise the test the results are meaningless. what a pity they dont have the sense to realise that themselves. complete waste of time, money and effort.

 You say:
Message: (1500 character limit)
(Using the Quick Post will also register you with the site)
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
  
  
 

Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Home > Forum > EquipmentForum jump  
Members Logon
Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?
Article search
Click to support GM