Sunday 23 November 2008 | Personalise | Help  
Free membership & newsletter
Join GOLFmagic now
Join today!
Free weekly newsletter
Free membership
why join?  
Latest Reviews
4386 Total Reviews
 FORUM
Discussions by:   Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
 Search forum: 
Component drivers
What's worth looking at?
1 to 20 of 20 messagesTo post a reply you need to be a member - Join now.
Show/hide user stats

I fancy a new driver, or at least one with a nicer shaft.

I currently have an Integra SoooLong Graph-Ti 10.5' with Integra regular shaft.  I generally hit it OK, pretty high flight (which is fine for me) but it can be a bit wayward at times (probably me as much as anything!!!).

I had considered putting a better shaft in it, but then, as we all do, I started to think about something new altogether!!

Been having a look around and it seems that the Geek DCT, SMT 455DB and Wishon 919 THI are all quite well regarded.

Are any of these clubs well suited to an average joe golfer?  I'm a high handicapper, not sure on swing speed (never been measured, but would consider it to be medium) tend to hit quite a high drive (tee the ball with equator level with top of driver), often straight, sometimes with a bit of fade.  When really bad it's a big duck hook, I don't tend to hit many big slices anymore.

My worry with some of the popular component heads in the US, being designed for long drive comps, and so maybe not as forgiving as some.

Can anyone comment on which heads may be worth a look?  Also, shafts, I have little experience with what 'suits' me as I've always tended to play OEM shafts in regular.  I recently bought an MD EQL that is fitted with a Proforce 65 Tip Active.  I hit this club much better than the last hybrid I carried (RAM with stock shaft) but how much of that is to do with head or shaft I don't know!

I'm happy to buy from the states, and either build up or try my luck at finding something that suits 2nd hand.

Show/hide user stats
There simply isn't anything better than Nakashima, mate
Show/hide user stats
I got a new custom made driver from Pure Forged based in Elgin. Probably a bit far away but can produce a driver based on some swing specs and stocks some nice stuff.
Show/hide user stats

Damn, both of those companies look like the produce some nice gear, but maybe a little more expensive than I'd hoped!!

How about suggestions based around similar price brackets to the SMT's, Geek's, etc

Show/hide user stats
Hallsy, not sure whats expensive - 3 of the Nakashima drivers on the first page are under £200. You'll pay more than that for most premium off the shelf drivers.
Show/hide user stats
Topslicehookpullsh**k wrote (see)
Hallsy, not sure whats expensive - 3 of the Nakashima drivers on the first page are under £200. You'll pay more than that for most premium off the shelf drivers.


Oh, I realise that, but then I rarely buy golf stuff brand new, and definately not when it first comes out at premium prices.

I thought that things like the Geek DCT I had mentioned could be had for around $150-200 all in from the US, even less 2nd hand?  They can be had in the UK for around £150 iirc.

Ben - never heard of them, but will take a look

Show/hide user stats
A few on here have a Geek, in fact Boa is surely to be along to praise his Geek (best he has ever owned apparently). i think the biggest problem that most people see with components is the sell on cost, compared to a named driver they are quite poor for sell on prices.
Show/hide user stats
Hallsy, here you go see thread....Geek for sale
Show/hide user stats
Thanks for the heads up, I have already spoken to Boa, it's a little bit soon for me as I am due to go on holiday next week so money is a touch tight until I'm back, but it's definately one to consider if it's about when I return
Show/hide user stats

Certain manufacturers such as Nakashima, Wishon, KZG bar their dealers from selling components-only, I.e. you have to buy assembled clubs. So if you want heads-only, you'll be looking secondhand on the USA forums.

The Wishon 919 driver is THE must-have head at the moment. Launches and spins a little higher than average, which makes it a few yards shorter than average, but this and an enormous face with huge sweet spot is giving it a reputation for being the most forgiving head of all time.

Nakashima is long, but not really forgiving, small-ish sweet spot, you need to be a better player. I built a driver and 3-wood for a chum - he won't play anything else now. I couldn't hit the driver very consistently, but that 3w was the longest club I've ever hit.

The PowerPlay Caiman (odd looking beast) is cheapie from Hireko but has a huge following on the component forums (check the fGI forum), very long and forgiving.

I have a few component heads, Wishon etc for sale, drop me a PM with your e-mail address and I'll send you pics and details.

Show/hide user stats

Thanks Regulator, I'll drop you a PM.

I think at the moment I am between the Geek DCT (had considered the FS3 but my mishit is usually on the toe, where the DCT is supposedly still pretty forgiving) and the Wishon 919.  I reckon on 11' loft.  SMT 455DB was in the running, but I'm not a lover of it's colour, and also hear conflicting reviews.

I had looked at the Caiman, but not to keen on the looks tbh.

I'm still a little clueless with the shafts though, and it's going to be difficult for me to demo some with the heads I'm interested in.

Show/hide user stats

Hallsy,

Try and contact Stickman on here, he has a garage full of all the drivers you want to try!! and is a top guy as well!!

Show/hide user stats
Cheers bud, might have to pay him a visit after my hols
This member’s stats are private
You ask if they are suited for the average golfer. Its not easy to answer! An average golfer could be a great ball striker, but a bad putter. But assuming you mean average ball striker, and around 10 handicap, I would suggest these are all clubs that MUST be tested first. And I've hit all the ones liosted except the Wishon.

The Geek DCT is still in my bag, but its a toughie, you have to hit pretty much in the centre, there is little forgiveness off centre and it launches low, plays very close to stated loft. I wasn't blown over by the 455, but love the Encore, which is as long as the DCT, but you have to loive with a Cobraesque noise, and ultimately the solid dtike of the DCT just won me over.
Show/hide user stats

Thanks for that wormburner, I know it is difficult to suggest components to people without seeing their game/swing, etc, but I suppose I was just looking for some general ideas.

I think as far as head choices go, any of the ones I have in mind will be good performers, ultimately it will be shaft choice that will make or break them for me.  My driving is usually reasonably consistant (in comparison to the rest of my inconsistant game!!), but when it goes downhill, it's hard to get up again!!

This member’s stats are private
Well the DCT aint for the faint hearted, although anyone can use it, if you are not consistently around the screws it can hurt a tad. It likes any good shaft tbh, I've played it with several and the head responds well to whatever you stick in it. I am currently using a Harrison Pro 95g
Show/hide user stats

Wormburner and Hallsey

I reckon that I have had MANY fine drivers right from the time when Harry Busson at Walton Heath-probably the greatest maker of persimmon drivers and fairway woods, produced drivers to my personal preferences regarding bulge and roll, loft, 1 degree toed out and depth of head, colour and insert material!  In those far-off days however graphite was not even on the horizon.

However, I can truthfully say that of all the graphite-shafted drivers I have had my Geek DCT has been the very best for looks, ease of use,length, straight hitting and consistent height. My only regret is that I bought it when I was still producing a reasonably quick swing speed for my age and now I still drive well with it but I'm losing length and at 72 I need ALL the length I can obtain with a softer, lighter shaft with more torque.

I have found that the Grafalloy Prologic 75 gramme Tour regular shaft is extremely stable and in the hands of a younger man who wants a GREAT driver it would be a real find. I could try a softer shaft but I really feel that it might never work as well again as it does now and,quite apart from money I really would hope that someone else will take the opportunity of getting the same-or greater pleasure out of it as I have. I have kept the head, face and shaft  like new, only the sole shows a little wear. 

Wormburner, you must be very big and strong with a swing speed in excess of 110 mph or thereabouts to use SUCH a heavy shaft!! I alwys reckoned that mine was heavy. I have never heard of ANYONE using a shaft as heavy as yours!

Edited: 08/09/08 09:31
Show/hide user stats
Nakashima, or failing that ahot melted TM tour driver head from fleabay for about £125, very very much better than the retail crap they spill out of China
Show/hide user stats
Drop Range Monkey a message either on here or Modsquadgolf forum, he is a fitter and stocks a lot of the manufactures mentioned above and will give you some great guidance on the heads and shafts. Alot of guys on from here and Modsquadgolf speak very highly of him.

 You say:
Message: (1500 character limit)
(Using the Quick Post will also register you with the site)
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
  
  
 

Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Home > Forum > Custom-fit and club makersForum jump  
Members Logon
Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?
Article search
Click to support GM