Welcome to GOLFmagic
Why should I become a member?
  •  
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Golf Courses
  • Golf Instruction
  • Golf Travel
  • Directory
  • Golf Forums
  • Golf Competitions
Join GolfMagic  
Advertise with us  
Take our articles (RSS)  
General News  
Tour News  
Equipment news  
Mens golf clubs  
Ladies golf clubs  
Golf bags and trolleys  
Competitions and give-aways  
Golf shoes and clothing  
Golf balls  
Golf books and videos  
Junior golf clubs  
Golf accessories  
Gear news  
Buyers' guides  
Shopping  
Book tee times  
Read and write course reviews  
Shopping  
Free handicap and score tracker  
Driving  
Putting  
Rescue shots  
General tips  
Golf travel offers  
Golf travel overseas  
Score tracker  
Tee Time Finder  
Shopping  
Travel  
Classifieds  
Golf Forums
You are looking at: Home : Golf Forums : Golf equipment
Driver Shaft replacement recommendations
 
Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum TopicsHelp | Settings | Public Profile
 Search forum: 
Driver Shaft replacement recommendations
Help please?
1 to 20 of 22 messagesPage: 1  2  
 
Show/hide user stats
Garry Baker
25/02/04 10:52
 154 forum posts 7 reviews 1 bookmark
I recently managed to get my hands on a bargin priced "Titleist 983K 10.5 degree" driver. Brilliant head, like it a lot, feel, draw bias, power with a boring flight. Problem though is that I'm not sold on the standard Titleist 4560 shaft (Reg flex) that's in it.

Thinking of replacing this shaft to make this driver the one to keep for the next seasons.

Happy with regular flex, always been measured at Reg flex swing speeds.

There seems to be a plethora of good aftermarket driver shafts but what should I be considering?

Grafalloy Blue - R-flex play too stiff?
Aldila One - not heard any reports?
Aldila NV65 - seems popular.
Proforce XL or Harmon CB.

Any thoughts or other recommendations greatly appreciated. Also need advice on where to get this replacement carried out - not all pro's seem able to get hold of quality replacement shafts or willing to fit them.

 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Steven Ferguson
25/02/04 12:14
 456 forum posts 5 reviews 1 bookmark
Aswell as SS, theres loads of other stuff to take into consideration.. torque, kick point, length, clubhead type, material used, swing tempo, accuracy / distance tradeoff. Your perfect shaft in one club may be crap in another.

Try to find as many demo clubs with the same head as yours. The shaft is the most important part of the club so you must make sure you get one that will work best for you.

I had my tour Launcher 400 fitted with an x100 a few weeks ago. It was done by www.xsgolf.com. Awesome service.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Newyorker (7.5)
25/02/04 12:53
 162 forum posts 6 reviews
Garry. When you decide on a shaft you might want to contact www.grahamtonge.co.uk who is based in Frodsham, Cheshire for a shaft fit. He is a professional golfer and clubmaker and offers a sales service and/or just a fitting if you supply the shaft. His service is very good and I can personally recommend him.

On the shaft selection bit - My SS is 92-95 mph and I fit at borderline regular/stiff but always go with regular as I have a smooth tempo. I shaft I tend to really get on with is the YS-6 by Graphite Design in regular flex. It's a great "swingers" shaft as opposed to a hitter and feels smooth.

You may want to get in touch with Jenny Mcguiness at Golfworks Europe. Golfworks can supply almost any shaft you require. Jenny can be contacted at jmcguinness@golfworks.com (TEL: +44 (0)1480 891311)

Hope this helps ;-)
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Smithy
25/02/04 13:57
 26 forum posts
The best option that I know of is to find out when there is a Titleist Demo Day in your area. They have staff there that can tell you the best shaft for you and you get to try all the gear beforehand! I think they usually have it on their web-site. Good luck.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Garry Baker
25/02/04 14:16
 154 forum posts 7 reviews 1 bookmark
Thanks for the info guys, much appreciated.

I have tied to hit other 983K's with differing shafts but its proving hard, most are cutom-fit only so the stock shaft seems to be only demo club you can get hold of.

Definitely a average tempo which can get rushed when I want to hit harder for length, it never works, I will remember this one day. I believe I'm looking for low kick point to get a higher flight maybe?

An interesting point on the current Titleist 4560 shaft, not sure if anyone can explain this one to me. Teeing the ball low, only a bit of the ball above the height of the club face gets a draw (good swing) to straight shot (okay swing) pattern. Flight lacks a bit of height in my eyes but then the ball is on a low tee. Trying a higher tee for a more sweeping shot should promote more of a draw I thought (magazine articles seem to indicate this is so) but not for me with this 983K driver, this one seems to get out to the right.

Thanks for recommending Graham, heard his name mentioned before, got him on my list to talk to once I have a shaft in mind.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Newyorker (7.5)
25/02/04 14:48
 162 forum posts 6 reviews
The low kick-point bit for a higher flight is correct yes. The Ys-6 is mid kick-point from memory I think.

The theory about the tee height is correct though, so I'm not sure why the higher teed ball would fly right and the lower one would draw!!
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Will Threeputt
25/02/04 18:28
 22 forum posts
I have the same 983K 10.5 with YS6 in Regular. It was a custom order. My driver swing speed is low to mid 90s.

It has a lower, more boring trajectory than the 4560. On contact, doesn't feel so soft as most stock shafts I've used. I think it feels stiffer than it actually plays. A nice smooth tempo gives great results for me. But unlike some other shafts I have tried, in the heat of battle, try a bit harder, and its still quite straight.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Paul Hodgson
25/02/04 20:41
 1149 forum posts 12 reviews
Go get yourself fitted with a rifle lite steel, you'll gain all the controls of steel without noticable loss of distance.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Garry Baker
26/02/04 07:38
 154 forum posts 7 reviews 1 bookmark
Paul,

Interested in your comments about putting in a Rifle lite steel shaft. Tempted by this idea myself, the most accurate driver I owned was a TM200 with a steel reg flex Rifle shaft, but lacked length over my 3-wood. My worries would be what a steel shaft would be like in a larger 365cc titanium driver, what length I would be able to generate and whether I would have ruined any re-sale value of the 983K club by dropping out the graphite shaft and replacing with steel.

What club head do you have the steel shaft in? Any reasonable loss in length? I'm not worried about the odd 10 yards or so.

Anyone used or have experience of either the Aldila One or Proforce XL? these shafts seem to be available at a sensible cost instead of the NV65 costs (£90) I have been quoted.

Thank you for all the info and help.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Steven Ferguson
26/02/04 10:58
 456 forum posts 5 reviews 1 bookmark
Garry I have a 44.5" dynamic gold x100 in my 400cc launcher. I hadnt played steel into titanium so it was a bit of a trial. the swingweight is D3. There has been no loss of distance [except maybe the once or twice a month real huge hit] but because of the increased accuracy i am more confident going after drives if i need the distance.

Adam scott plays a dynamic gold lite in his 983.

you may aswell try steel, you'll be able to get fitted for one and have it put in for around £30 quid. so even if you dont like it, theres no great loss.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Darth Fader
26/02/04 11:26
 576 forum posts 2 bookmarks
Garry,

There are plenty of low cost alternatives available in steel and in graphite and some excellent suggestions have been made above. My thoughts on the reshaft are as follows:

The 983 is a thru-Bore hosel configuration and will play almost a whole flex stiffer with some shafts. You therefore need to consider shafts that are specifically designed for thru-bore heads or a regular flex will play to a firm/stiff - so be careful with what you choose!!

I am happy to suggest some shafts that should fit the bill but I will need some more information about your swing etc to make an informed recommendation:

Are you a 'Hitter' or a 'swinger' i.e. do you have a smooth and fluid swing or do you put the power on from the top aggressively?

How for (carry only) do you, on average, hit your driver, 5 iron and 7 iron?

Do you want a higher or lower trajectory?

What is your 'nightmare' shot? slice, hook?

Do you want/need a shorter shaft length?



 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Garry Baker
26/02/04 12:13
 154 forum posts 7 reviews 1 bookmark
Darth,

Many thanks, info below;

'Swinger' rather than a 'hitter', hitting has never worked with me, I end up on an outside-to-in line, so have always tried to keep it fluid.

Higher trajectory would be nice, but I'm fairly sure I'm artificially keeping it low with the low tee (see response above for the reason which still makes no sense to me).

Definitely interested in a shorter shaft, was thinking of 44.5 or preferably 44 inches.

Nightmare shot is a slice, only get this with driver if I try hitting it too hard really.

Finally, 7 iron carry 145, 5-iron carry 160 (tails off explaining my liking of TM Rescue clubs). Driver, approx 220 carry in present conditions with a good swing.

Any advice appreciated. What are your thoughts on Steel for a 983K?
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Darth Fader
26/02/04 13:14
 576 forum posts 2 bookmarks
Garry,

For steel shaft - I would suggest you look at the True Temper TX-90 in a reg flex. It will be a good match for the 983 and it is a sweet shaft. Mid/Low kickpoint, lightweight & the shaft should cost around 10 quid + fitting.

For a graphite shaft, you fit the Reg flex Graphite design YS-6 quite well. Mid kickpoint & soft in the tip section for a higher launch angle and it has excellent feel. It may play a tad soft for you - if so you may want to consider tip trimming by 1/2 inch or so. Shaft should cost around 35-40 quid plus fitting.

Hope this helps.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Ste Robinson
26/02/04 20:30
 2362 forum posts 25 reviews 1 bookmark
All the major manufacturers sites give guidelines on shaft fitting. Here's a few for you to look at

http://www.grafalloy.com/grafalloy.htm
http://www.aldila.com/
http://www.truetemper.com/
http://www.ustgolfshaft.com/dev/index.htm
http://www.royalprecision.com

May be of some help, or may just confuse you even more ;-)
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Garry Baker
27/02/04 07:45
 154 forum posts 7 reviews 1 bookmark
Darth,

Got any thoughts on an Aldila 'One' shaft for my 983K? The 65g regular flex with 'high launch' has been recommended as they (local club fitters) cannot get hold of the YS-6.

They can do the steel option, the TX-90 and have quoted £60 all in - reasonable price?

The 'One' would be £100.

Thanks for the info, much appreciated.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Darth Fader
27/02/04 08:12
 576 forum posts 2 bookmarks


Garry,

I have never it the Aldila One so I cannot comment.

The thru-bore reshaft it a little more complicated than others so the club builder may charge a little extra - but 60 quid is a bit steep for the TX 90. 100 quid for the One is also a bit steep.

Where do you live? Perhaps I could suggest somebody near you....

Failing that, Warren has made some good suggestions above which you may want to try. Alternatively you could call David Doyle who has contributed to this site and seems very competent....
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Garry Baker
27/02/04 09:08
 154 forum posts 7 reviews 1 bookmark
Cheers Darth, great advice as always. I'm in Nottingham, any shaft fitter suggestions welcome.

 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
mark harrison
27/02/04 13:06
 84 forum posts 2 reviews
Gary

Totally recommend Graham Tonge as per Warren's recommendations.
He has just re-shafted my driver wit ha Grafalloy Power-lite for £64 all in.
Give him a call or better still book a session with him if you are local, well worth it.

Mark.....
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Paul Hodgson
27/02/04 20:10
 1149 forum posts 12 reviews
Garry

I know I suggested steel but if you're set on graphite I've a Graffaloy ProLit 35+ r flex for £30 you can buy. Graham Tonge took it out of my Mizuno driver to replace with the steel shaft I mentioned before.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Darth Fader
28/02/04 19:16
 576 forum posts 2 bookmarks
Garry,

Sorry, don't know anybody in Nottingham.
 Send to friend
 
1 to 20 of 22 messages

Page: 1  2  


Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Forum jump  
Become a member and join in the forum!
Calendar
To search for a local course please enter a distance and your postcode:
To book a local tee click Here >>
Free golf score and handicap tracker. Record your stats,
analyse your round,
improve your game!
Click here
Calendar
Why Tiger chose Masters for his return - Published in News
Woods feels comfortable and secure at Augusta - 17/3/10
Golf Express airline soon to take off - Published in News
New travel idea launches in April - 12/3/10
Tiger's comeback for Bay Hill (March 25)? - Published in News
Mickelson set to lock horns with World No.1 at Arnold Palmer event - 12/3/10
  • Puma buys Cobra Golf brand
  • The English are coming!
The Grip Master
Golfballs.gg
'JamGolf - Golf Clearance'
Forgan St. Andrews - Custom Golf Clubs
TM Golf Shops
Golf Store Europe
Great Value Golf
GolfOnline.co.uk
Golfmagic on Twitter
Facebook

Become a fan of RCUK

Twitter

Follow us on twitter

Visit our sister site Bikemagic.com

Click here

Meet the Team

Click here

Other Magicalia Sites

Parenting

  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums

Active

  • AVReview
  • BIKEmagic
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • RoadCyclingUK
  • Visordown

About GOLFMagic

  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & conditions
  • Support
  • Advertise with us

Forums

  • New to the forum?
  • General
  • Magic action
  • Golf instruction
  • Golf equipment
  • Golf courses
  • Have clubs, will travel
  • Golf fitness
  • Other sports
  • Pro Tours
  • Custom-fit and club makers
  • Golf rules & handicapping
  • Fancy a game?
  • The 19th hole
  • Feedback/Help desk
  • GOLFmagic League
  • Classifieds/Swap Shop

Competitions

  • Competitions
  • Free handicap and score tracker
  • Golf travel offers
  • Online tee times

Golf Courses

  • Book tee times
  • Read and write course reviews
  • Shopping

Golf Tips

  • Free handicap and score tracker
  • Driving
  • Putting
  • Rescue shots
  • General tips

Travel

  • Golf travel offers
  • Golf travel overseas

Home

  • Join GOLFMagic
  • Advertise with us
  • Take our articles (RSS)

News

  • News
  • Tour News
  • Equipment News

Reviews

  • Competitions and give-aways
  • Equipment News
  • Buyers' guides
  • Shopping
© 1999-2010 Magicalia Ltd. Part of the Magicalia group www.magicalia.com