Instruction articles
You are looking at: Home : Instruction articles

Hot topic: Why do we make such stupid blunders?

'I was out in level par and back in an ambulance!' Who knows the secret of golfing suicide in the monthly medal?


Posted: 26 April 2004
by Bob Warters


Van de Velde at Carnoustie

Golf can be a cruel game. It produces highs and lows – not only in scoring but emotionally, too. Just when you think you’ve cracked it – the game jumps up and bites you in the backside and sends you home riddled with ‘if-only’ regrets.

And I’m speaking from personal experience.

Following a winter of not-so-much discontent but inconsistency, I wanted to get off to a flying start and chip away at my handicap back into the single figures I’d enjoyed 30 years ago. With a little more time to play, years of experience behind me and the equipment – balls, irons and drivers – so much improved, it didn’t seem a tall order.

And after nine holes of the year’s first medal on Saturday – and despite an opening bogey - I’d played solidly with seven pars, and a birdie. My 11 handicap was looking tasty and all kinds of ‘what-ifs’ were drifting in an out of my consciousness.

Three poor chips and a three-putt later I’d dropped four shots with three holes to play and started to panic. A double and triple bogey followed and an excellent round had metamorphosised into mediocrity.


Psychologist Jos Vanstiphout

Out in level par, back in an ambulance!

At 16, instead of taking my punishment when semi-blocked by a tree I’d tried to hit a career fade and finished up in a hazard. At 18, a little voice inside has said ‘go for it!’ and I’d attempted to play a long iron from a downhill lie over water. …you guessed it.

But my question is: What makes golfers make stupid, rash decisions after playing so tidily? Why take risks when level-headedness is called for? If someone out there has the secret I want to know it – in fact, we all do.


Bob Warters - crazy decisions

It may not have helped my cause (and maybe it bruised me subconsciously) to have listened to Radio Five’s Adrian Chiles’ top ten sporting blunders on the way to the course – with No8 identified as Jean Van de Velde’s aberration at the 72nd hole off the 1999 Open Championship at Carnoustie.

Perhaps I should have heeded the warning.

When it comes to pro golfers having mental coaches like Jos Vanstephout (Ernie Els), Bob Rotella (Darren Clarke) or Jay Brunza (Tiger Woods) I’ve always been a sceptic. It merely seemed like a slap on the wrist, wrapped up in a £50,000 invoice.

But perhaps there’s more to it – and if so I’d have paid for it handsomely – well at least a tenner - on the back nine at the weekend. The experience has merely left me, bitter and frustrated -until the next time.

If anyone out there has a quick fix to avoid making crazy mistakes with a good card going I want to hear it.

Tell us on the forum if you have a secret to mental success on the golf course that you’re prepared to share. Let us know, too if you’ve been screwed by psychology!


Previous article Previous article:
King Cobra SZ 400 & 440 drivers
Next article:Next article
Tees could win you a Fortune!

TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle

Discuss this story

I had the same thing happen on Friday but this came from my own over ambitous play. Having put my tee shot in the rough down the right hand side I had a choice of playing a fade out of the rough through a gap of about 4 feet between 2 trees (never even tried this type of shot before) or to chip out onto the fairway. Anyway my male ego got the better of me and I decided to go for it. Well Tiger would have been happy with it im sure, it was bloody perfect, and rolled just onto the green. The downside of this was that any bit of trouble, or just a simple lay up became an attempted draw/fade or a gamble over the water. Anyway what started as a good round for me soon ended up as not one of my best. My conclusion to this is that we are males and have somthing in our brains that makes us do these stupid things even if we no that they are totaly beyong our level of skill. As men we will always have the what if you make it and the 1 great shot always outways the 50 bad ones that came before. We are men, we need are egos boosted on a regular basis and if no one will do it for us we have to try and do it our selves. :o)
Posted: 26/04/2004 13:19

How much better does that make me feel? Not a lot, but thanks for the sympathy that I think was in your message somewhere.
So it's a man thing, then - a macho mistake.

I'd love to hear a woman golfer's point of view. Who's out there? ED
Posted: 26/04/2004 14:18

The ammount of Times I have said to myself walking up to the ball, "take a short iron play it back to the fairway out of the long rough and use your handicapp". It normally ends up I am standing over the ball, 5 wood in hand and visions of the ball being next to the pin. Needless to say 90% of the time the next shot is exactly the same scenario!

The sad thing is the times I listen to the little voice and actually take the short Iron I get out of trouble and it all works out.

My analysis is that I only look at the ball and whereit is sitting and forget about all the things that could go wrong if I "go for it".

I went a long way to proving this to myself when I played in a 3 clubs and a putter competition and probably played the most consistent 18 I have ever played!!
Posted: 26/04/2004 14:59

well, if my game is anything to speak for ladies game in general, i am afraid the problem is not simply a 'male, macho' thing Cider.

Being a 20 handicapper, my game is not consistent, even on my best rounds. I am very likley to find myself in trouble quite often during a round, and have on more occasions than not, tried to hit myslef out of impossible situations rather than take my punishment and chip safelty out back onto the fairway.

It generally never works in my favour but yet when in these situations, always find myself tending to go for the rash shot rather than percentage play.
granted, i have learnt to control this stupid thinking more and more. yet, if I've missed a few easy putts, or fluffed my drive etc, my anger/frustration will often get the better of me and I'll revert to these suicidal shots again.

its not an easy answer Bob, but I can vouch for it not being simply a male ego thing!
Posted: 26/04/2004 15:30

In one of my better moments in golfing history, several years ago, I knew I was playing well and just focused on every shot. I know I had a double, a lot of pars, and a couple of birdies and an eagle. My partner gave no indication of what my score was but on the Tee box of the 17th I could not resist and decided to add it up. I just could not believe it 1 under gross. I immediately followed that with a double bogey and a triple. I lost my focus, and was thinking about the congratulations I was going to receive. Never been in that situation again. Just shows what pressure, and being in an unknown situation can do to your game.
Posted: 26/04/2004 16:00

1. Take on the shot and make certain par or maybe even birdie.

2. Chip out and go for the one putt par and no worse than a safe bogie.

If you had full stats on the above I reckon a reasonable golfer would rate:-

Option 1 = double bogie average and career total adding up to lots of dropped shots.

Option 2 = 0.5 over par average and career total of 25% over par compared to the Option 1 total.

I don't reckon anyone will argue with what the smart option to take is. So why do we so often go the other way and end up fuming?

I don't think it is macho I think it is hardwired into the human psyche. It is a gamble and, as per all other gambles, the odds are stacked against you. Odds don't stop people playing the lottery, bookies etc, so they won't stop them taking on the shots.

Jeez, I reckon I take on shots nearly every week whose chance of success make the lottery look like short odds!
Posted: 26/04/2004 16:09

Helen what does it feel like when the tough shot comes off?

Great, amazing all the bad shots are forgotten. It may not just be a man thing or just that we all have ego's and others, the more calm and methodical thinking among us tend not to let it get in their way as much.

Or on the other hand Helen you've got balls.

To go for the shot I mean :o)
Posted: 26/04/2004 17:51

I saw Monty on Sky last year and he said that he never wants to walk off a golf course and say "what if". "What if" I didn't go for the career best, "what if" I laid up short of the water, instead of going in it, etc. etc. If that does not work do what I do, stop speaking to my caddie, storm off giving the radio 5 presenter the "bird" and refusing to talk the press.....
Posted: 26/04/2004 20:43

Golf is a mind boggling game, how many times when you hit a crap drive, you end up recovering to make par. On the other hand how many times do hit a 250 yd plus drive down the middle and end up making double bogey.
Point I am trying to make is, when you relax and don't expect too much, sometimes you surprise yourself - when you hit that great drive your looking for birdie and you f**k up!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted: 26/04/2004 23:32

Had a little play round 10 holes with 2 wedges and a putter the other day, the worst I got was a double bogie on one of the longer holes, reckon it was 'cos I couldn't hit it far enough to get into some of the trouble I usually find, especially with a card. It doesn't matter how many times I tell myself (and anyone listening) that I'm going to play 'safety first'. It really is the odd freaky shot that does the damage. I agree with Jim, I've lost count the number of times I've nailed a drive only to totally screw up the second.
Posted: 27/04/2004 03:40

The funny thing is when I am playing doubles I never have this problem, because I am ruining someone else's card I always try to go for the escape rather than the spectacular. In singles medal I am always pushing for that little bit extra, great when it comes off but seven times out of ten it goes wrong.
Posted: 27/04/2004 07:40

Sunday: 21pts on the front 9 off a H'cap of 20 (my actual h'cap is 25 but the lads I play with will have none of it). This included a birdie on the 9th. 9 over for 9 holes - easy!

10pts off the 2nd nine including 2 lost balls on the 10th and 17th EACH! The lad who won it is off 23.x, they played him off 18 and he got 35pts.

And they call me a bandit!!!
Posted: 27/04/2004 08:27

to answer your question Cider, it feels great when I pull a tough shot off. As I never expect 100% to pull the shot off, i generally feel vindicated unless I end up in a worse position after the shot! (it happens!)

On the occasions I play the easy pitch out to the fairway, the number of times I have duffed the next shot (from the fairway) are too many to count. This is the most maddening!!!! so to avoid this rather common situation, I often just choose the hit and hope to save my blood pressure from rising to unnatural levels!
Posted: 27/04/2004 11:02

The best piece of advice I have ever received is the "80/20" rule, whereby if you can play the shot 8 times out of 10 then go for it, otherwise take the next best option. I think it also depends on the format you are playing...a matchplay situation might require that you go for it more than in a medal where it is all about getting the ball round without too much damage!


Posted: 27/04/2004 12:46

Bob
Congratulations on justifying a legendary piece of handicap protection, keeping your 11 in place for the high profile titles later in the year. You clearly had a fantastic front nine and thought "I don't want to get my handicap cut in the April medal when I could be the idol of the club in the presidents putter in July". Either that or you are already working on your next article, entitled "How £1500 of free equipment from those lovely people at XYZ Golf Company transformed me to a single figure golfer".

Joking apart, something that I find very useful if I've carved a drive into the deep stuff on a par 4 (not that this ever happens of course) is to stand over my second shot and say to myself "OK, this is now a par four FROM HERE - I might get down in 3 more (ie make a "birdie") but if I can get down in four from here that is fine." And guess what - why you do that you usually take 5 and sometimes chip it close and make a par 4 that really boosts your confidence. In my experience, it's not the great shots you hit that affect your score as much as how you deal with the inevitable poor shots.

And one final thought - thanks for bringing up Carnoustie again. I had a tenner on Van de Velde at 150/1!!
Posted: 27/04/2004 12:49

If we played the game for a living I think we would play more cautiously, as we don't the joy of hitting the dream shot far outweighs the cost of another lost ball and a triple bogey, IMHO.

I agree with the 80/20 rule but in reverse. If I think I could pull the shot off 20% of the time I'm going to have a pop.

I 'spose it helps I have a very relaxed attitude on the course so dont get down on myself even when having a howler. 1 shot at a time and all that :-)
Posted: 27/04/2004 14:20

It's in all our nature to go for it, man woman or other (hey it's the 200's now you know).
If we always went with the safe shot we would never learn a thing or progress.
If mankind didn't go for it we would all be running round with bugger all on except for a animal fur of some sort, grunting at each other and freezing are buts off because we thought fire was to scary to try and manipulate.

There,that feels better now blame iton your animal instints of survival.

:o)
Posted: 27/04/2004 14:27

Helen you are commiting a cardinal sin if you don't commit to the shot 100% you will fluff it more often.
Or in my case go flat out 110% and end up worse of than where you started.
Posted: 27/04/2004 14:30

In this case , you said it , thinking about your speech and handicap not the next shot.

It also works the other way , you play like a pratt for nine holes , reallise you have no chance relax and play the back nine level.

The answer is easy , play one shot at a time , doing it is the hard bit.

If you can find a tape of Bernhard Langer I am fairly sure it was when he won the Masters , he birdied 17 smiled then set is face like rock. So OK I've won but have to play the 18th to get the prize.
Posted: 27/04/2004 15:57

Just remembered.

Dave Pelz on Mickelson.

Because everyone said he had a great short game he played unbelievable shots , and never won a major.
Once he accepted he did not have to play great shots , just get up and down he won.


Posted: 27/04/2004 16:01

Hey you cheeky sod, Clifton! As if I'd protect my handicap! It was just that I blew up big time as soonas I started thinking further ahead than the next shot - and bad went to worse. Thanks for the sound advice, however.
By the way, thought we might have seen you at the Dubai World Cup (where we were on holiday) - unless that WAS you in the Tote hospitality enclosure, dressed in fancy dress as a sheik...no sorry, that WAS a sheik! Apologies for opening old wounds with the Van de Velde bet. ED


Posted: 27/04/2004 16:29

on my last round i hit a low hook onto a green out of some trees, a low cut out of some trees onto the green and a high fade around some trees onto the green yet failed to get hit any "simple" 100 yard pitches onto the green! i think its about concentration, i concentrate on hard shots and pull 'em off i don't concentrate on "easy" shots and mess them up!! so i think concentration is the key.
Posted: 27/04/2004 18:45

Another take on it all, I quite often get to the course early, (especially when I have gone easy on the pop the night before)and get onto the practise ground. It's amazing after a few duff shots how easy it is to get into the groove, shot after shot (apart from the odd miscue) goes down the middle.

Could it be that it's the odd miscue that surfaces during the actual round and because we can't immediately hit another one to get it out of our system, we let it affect us probably more than it should do. Subconciously we are all looking for a reason not to play well,after all its easier isn't it!!

A bit heavy I know, but I have been playing this game a long time and it's true, most of it is in the mind. Play well!
Posted: 28/04/2004 13:47

Blimey! That's deeper than the bunker short of the 4th on the Hotchkin, John! ED


Posted: 28/04/2004 15:45

Ever been in the "tin cup" situation? You just know you can make it so you keep on trying from the original spot instead of taking a closer drop?

I have....hence playing off 23!
Posted: 30/04/2004 02:06

Bob
Just kidding. email me at aclifton@tote.co.uk and we'll get together for a game. You wear the sheikhs outfit and give me 4 shots and you've got yourself a match!
best regards
Andy
Posted: 01/05/2004 22:43

Have also joined the not so exclusive "snatching defeat out of the jaws of victory club"
Cruising in the May medal at the weekend... 6 over gross on the (more difficult) front 9 off my 20 h/cap ....yep blue up with an OB on back nine par 5 (took 8) and an 8 on the next par 3
Ended up with 4 over.. net 74
What a game!
Posted: 03/05/2004 22:14

Bob
Sorry to be 2 months late but i've just seen this thread.

When I first saw your "miserable face" picture next to the article you looked remarkably like Howard Clark!

Nice!
Posted: 01/07/2004 19:29

I've met Howard a few times and he keeps doing a double take as if to say 'the last time I saw that face, I was looking in the mirror!'

Despite his bad press as a player - with more caddies than a Darjeeling tea-planter - he was always top man when we phoned for an opinion, a course/tournament preview or a reader tip.

Some may not care for his on course observations (in the forum) but he talks so much sense and was always a classy golfer with a great swing. And when for a Sky preview of the Players Championship at Sawgrass a couple of years he holed an 8-iron borrowed from Darren Clarke at the island green 17th at 7 in the morning - respect!
Posted: 02/07/2004 09:19

We'd love you to add a comment! Please take half a minute to register as a free member

Become a member and join in the forum!
Calendar

Track your game

Free golf score and handicap tracker. Record your stats,
analyse your round,
improve your game!
Click here
Calendar