Saturday 22 November 2008 | Personalise | Help  
Free membership & newsletter
Join GOLFmagic now
Join today!
Free weekly newsletter
Free membership
why join?  
Latest Reviews
4386 Total Reviews
 REVIEWS 09 / 01 / 08
 

New series: We try the latest drivers

testing golf clubs

This week we introduce a new series of columns by leading equipment expert Dominic Pedler, long-time authority on golf technology and trends.

Dominic has been revealing what's next in our bags for nearly 20 years, including stints as equipment editor with Golf World and currently Golf International as well as working on Chris Evans' Tee Time TV series on Channel 4. He has also contributed to numerous publications including Pro Shop Europe and Greenside as well as The Times, FHM and the acclaimed 'Eyewitness' series of books.

He kicks off with a whirlwind analysis of the latest new-fangled drivers he has already tried and tested. Dominic has been a member at Roehampton Golf Club for over 30 years.

testing golf equipment
Dominic Pedler takes a bunch of clubs for a New Year's Day driving test

THE SHAPE OF DRIVERS TO COME

Never mind the sluggish Christmas sales, golf equipment is set to buck the New Year consumer slowdown - courtesy of the R&A. Many of us now have the perfect excuse to splash out on one of the latest high-tech drivers in readiness for the new season.

After years of confusion and exemptions since the first announcement back in 2002, the rules limiting the 'spring-like' effect on driving clubs finally came into force for all golfers on January 1.

While admittedly, most models manufactured over the last few years are already in the conforming, I know many of golfers who have still to replace their non-conforming and now illegal 'hot-faced' big stick. And as Golfmagic warned recently, there is still plenty of scope for controversy. Those in doubt should check the lists of non-conforming clubs published by the R&A.

All golfers will surely be tempted by some of the latest drivers with exotic geometry and adjustable weighting, as designs take some fascinating twists and turns.

testing golf clubs
Cleveland XLS HiBore driver

CLEVELAND HI-BORE XLS

My Christmas came a few days early when I took delivery of a new batch of Cleveland HiBore XLS drivers - the 2008 upgrade of the model used so successively by Tour players Vijay Singh and Woody Austin.

With its distinctive scooped-back 'sunken crown', designed to line up the centre of gravity precisely with the hottest part of the face (unlike many of its more conventional 460cc rivals), the HiBore concept pioneered the trend in whacky shapes long before the 'square' became the new fashion.

The third-generation XLS model (£249) bites back with a subtly amended profile featuring more angular contouring (which helps with alignment) and a 17% larger face, which I found significantly more forgiving than the shallow-faced original.

As always, choose carefully from the various options which, as well as the standard model, now includes a Draw version (with a face closed 3-degrees) and Tour model (2-degrees open).

Shaft choice is equally essential, as I found when, in my post-Christmas lethargy, I had difficulty squaring its face with the 60g Fujikura Stiff flex but found I could work the softer, 55g Regular almost at will.

WILSON STAFF SPINE v COBRA LV4

Cleveland's sunken crown (first seen on its excellent Halo hybrid) has clearly been an inspiration for other new 'low-profile' rivals, including the Wilson Staff Spine and King Cobra L4V drivers.

Golf clubs on test
Wilson Staff Spine

The Spine (£229) gets its name from the central ridge which reinforces the face of a club which Padraig Harrington played in the Pro-Am for the Dunhill Links though it's being customized for the Irishman.

The “High MOI, Low CG” stamp on the toe of the club encapsulates the techie message from several other new premium drivers this season. And talking of buzzwords, the King Cobra L4V manages a veritable techie 'Grand Slam' b y taking all four R&A clubhead variables to their allowable limits - a Moment Of Inertia of 5,900g/cm2, 460cc volume, maximum 5x 5-inch head dimensions and clubface COR of 0.83.

I took the L4V for a test drive on New Year's Day and, despite the delicate condition (me rather than the club), was impressed with the 'rainbow' flight (a trendy term for today's favoured 'arcing', rather than 'climbing' flight) that was easily achievable without teeing the ball excessively high.

This suggests that the weighting has been improved from the early Cobra Speed series from which the L4V has clearly evolved, though now with a rather elegant, longer head featuring pronounced aerodynamic 'dimples' in the crown.

The resulting low CG presumably explains why I enjoyed hitting a nice high launch despite a lower loft than my usual 10.5 degree spec, and which (together with the 57g Diamana shaft option suited to ballspeeds in the 125-155 mph range), seemed to reduce my excessively high driver spin.

I look forward to some number-crunching on the TrackMan on my next visit to expert custom fitters, Precision Golf, in my eternal quest to lock-in my ideal launch conditions.

golf clubs on test
Nike Sumo2 5900 square driver

I can't leave driver geometry without noting that square heads have long outlasted TaylorMade's original 'give it three months' claim. Sure enough, Nike have refined their latest square-headed Sumo driver both to improve the notoriously tinny sound of the original, while (like Cobra) milking the Moment Of Inertia to the max.

NIKE SQ SUMO2

The Nike SQ Sumo2 5900 is even named after the rule-makers' 5,900 g/cm2 official limit - which presumably limits the scope for future “resistance to twisting” claims that have so dominated driver marketing over the last few years.

I managed to stay mostly on the straight and narrow with the club at Nike's product launch last autumn, with the sound clearly improved (deeper rather than high pitched) - though probably still loud enough to bother KJ Choi's playing partners!

Incidentally, Nike's No1 staff player Tiger Woods, says the only reason he hasn't 'gone square' is because the club is so straight he can't shape it around doglegs. That's good enough for me - or at least it was until the R&A's technical guru, Dr. Steve Otto, explained that the accuracy benefits of high-MOI clubs comes with a health warning.

“As long as you square the clubface at impact," Otto told me when we spoke at the R&A's test centre, "a golf ball struck with a high MOI club will go much straighter along the target line as there will be less sidespin.

"But if the face is either open or closed at impact you will still go left or right. In which case, a high MOI club won't improve your dispersion - in fact it might take you further into the rough!” he added soberingly.

golf clubs on test
Yonex Nanospeed-i

YONEX NANOSPEED-i

Trumping the square heads is the pentagonal shaped Yonex Nanospeed-i driver which won the top product award at the influential Golf Europe tradeshow in Munich in October.

Aerodynamics is the name of the game here, with the intricate rear sole section claiming to reduce the wind resistance associated with conventional deep-faced designs. Yonex scientists argue that improving the airflow around the structure leads to both faster head speeds and a more stable flight.

I'm still waiting for a sample to try but a fellow equipment tester assures me he gets a Trackman-confirmed three mph extra ballspeed (that's about six yards more carry). And apparently the sound of the graphite/titanium mix is more aesthetically pleasing than earsplitting all-titanium ballistics.

BEST OF THE REST

Other elaborate new driver designs for 2008 include Srixon's Z-RW which focuses on a 'curving projection sole' that varies weighting according to loft option. It also has a forged titanium face sporting four separate zones claimed to control sidespin by optimizing the gear effect across a wider area.

golf clubs on test
Callaway Hyper X

But not all companies are buying into exotic shapes and high fallutin' science. It's ironic, surely, that Callaway follows up its lavish square-headed FT-i with the Hyper-X driver, a disarmingly no-frills, all-titanium head that is nevertheless destined to be big on Tour this season.

Similarly, apart from a slightly deeper face and longer body, the new Ping G10 is hardly a quantum change. However, says Ping chief John Solheim: “a lot of little improvements add up to significant performance gains.

At least it's enough to convince Angel Cabrera (who won the Singapore Open in November) despite his phenomenal driving with the Ping Rapture at last summer's US Open.

Finally, adjustable weighting remains a powerful trend, with the TaylorMade r7CGB Max (£329) promising as much as a 30-yard draw if you programme the 16-gramme and [pair of] one-gramme weights appropriately.

golf clubs on test
Changing the 'fast track' weights on the Mizuno MP-600

Taylor Made is also 'going big' on its SuperFast shaft technology which combines an ultra-light and longer (46-inch) RE*AX graphite shaft with an ultra-light grip, claiming to generate more clubhead speed for increased distance.

And 2008 should be a good year for slicers or at least those who want to oust that destructive curve ball from their game. They should check out the revolutionary Mizuno MP-600 driver, with its sliding system of moveable weights behind the head. This FastTrack system is an undeniably clever take on the adjustable theme, being both innovative and simple to use in practice.

Admittedly there are anecdotal reports that the MP-600 is not the longest of new drivers - at the club's official launch top coach Denis Pugh appeared to hit Mizuno's the non-adjustable, cheaper (and louder!) MX-560, a few yards further - like Luke Donald, I was impressed when taking what is already 2008's most talked about new driver for an 18-hole test drive.

Adjustment, according to the Rules of Golf, should only be made between rounds but, purely for research purposes, I cheekily tweaked the settings on almost every tee to sample some of the 15 possible flight variations promoting varying degrees of bias from fade to draw.

Now, if only the R&A would change that rule!

*Dominic will be back next month with a report on the annual PGA Merchandise Show in Orlando, Florida - including a round up of his favourite new irons for 2008, and the latest on Phil Mickelson's Callaway X-Muscle blades.


Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Comment on this in our forum:
 You say:
Using this form will also register you with the site.
Message:
Read member reviews:
Drivers (Men) (360 products)
Related articles:
Cleveland' launches new irons and drivers
'HiBore XLi irons, take hybrid sets to a new level'
Chance to test drivers and play The Grove
Do you meet the criteria we need?
Srixon shoot-out: Day to remember
How clash of legends proves just the ticket for Ben
Wilson Staff Spine driver review
In the right hands and at the right price the Spine can add some backbone and stability to your game
How far could you hit your driver?
...Mizuno dates will tell you your optimum
How Cobras bit the Tiger
Ogilvy's Cobra clubs end World No.1's winning streak
Callaway truck's on the road
Get fitted when it stops near you!
King Cobras - new and improved
Speed LD-F and Speed LD-M drivers' new dimensions
Nike, Wilson Staff set for UK Golf Show
Top brands to use outdoor ranges for golfers to try equipment
Power - and the glory!
Cobra's J B Holmes crushes Mickelson with 359-yard play-off tee shot
Mix and match - the latest craze
Trade Show unveils the latest equipment including how to adjust your set to suit you
Illegal driver ignorance!
New rules 'could takes years' to filter through
Driver fit: What you need to know
It's time to make your move for a new weapon of choice
Mizuno claims new drivers are tested yards further
'Our research shows the new conforming drivers are ‘playing’ extremely hot'
Cleveland HiBore XLS range set for February
Large, ultra-forgiving heads can prove a big hit!
Nike SQ Sumo2 hybrid (17 deg)
A leap forward in terms of hybrid design
Callaway's agreement with TaylorMade
Each company will have rights to make products under patents owned by the other
Tiger wins with new Nike ball
Plus Titleist claims world records...Kingston's putter switch
Nike signs Dyson
Yorkshire golfer to play square-headed 5900 driver
Tiger's equipment secrets
Revealing thoughts on hybrids, wedges and the standardised ball
Square driver: Why Tiger doesn't use it
Woods' revealing interview at Nike 360 Fitting System launch
Callaway reveals prototype X Muscle irons
Mickelson and Els already have them in their bags
'Ultimate Forgiveness' from Cobra
UFi irons will have an unusual polymer top line when revealed in February
New toys for old boys!
Golfmagic.com asks Tour veterans how they're adapting to new stuff
Orka KiiSD driver
Old shaft given a new lease of life with a modern head
Srixon buys Cleveland brand
Surprise deal sees sees strength of balls and wedges under one umbrella
Driver ideas! To replace those illegal clubs
By January non-conforming drivers break the law. So try these, instead!
Drivers: New and 'seriously powerful'
Harrington tests 'The Spine'; latest from Callaway, Nike and Srixon
Callaway aims to steal the show!
New range of hardway with that X factor to be revealed in Munich
'More trial, less error'
Why new technology is changing the face of golf, by Monty's coach Denis Pugh
Mizuno's 'slide and twist' driver
Weights on the MP-600 driver are slid into position to create different trajectories and ball flights.
Mr Chalk v Mr Cheese!
The difference between Mickelson and Els when it comes to choosing the Callaway equipment to suit them

Members Logon
Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?
Article search
Click to support GM